This past Sunday, 2/9/14, we sang Paul Tate’s ‘You are the Light of the World.’ This is not a new song at all, but it was for us. We’d never sung it before. (Maybe once…but it was awhile ago.) The lyrics are taken right from the readings for the Fifth Sunday in Ordinary Time, Cycle A. It was the perfect song to use as a gathering song, but I was a little concerned that the people wouldn’t join right in since it was new to them.
If we were to rehearse and sing it as written in the score, it would’ve gone like this:
1. Start with a 7 bar introduction which uses the
last half of the refrain melody (which is helpful)2. Sing the Refrain in unison
3. Sing Verse 1
4. Sing the Refrain with harmonies and descant
5. Sing Verse 2…etc.
This is a perfectly good ‘map’ or flow for this song if all
are familiar with it. But since it was new, I
asked everyone to play it this way:
1. Play the entire Refrain as the introduction, with the melody very pronounced (RH of piano or solo instrument. Consider switching instruments on the second half of the Intro for variety.) This enables everyone to hear the melody clearly before it is sung. It gets it into their ears.
2. Sing the Refrain in unison (as written) – no harmonies
3. Repeat the Refrain – sing it again! Why not? They’ve only heard it once. This time around they will feel more comfortable and more inclined to join in singing. Ask the band to play out a little more fully. Also…don’t sing the descant part, yet. That’ll just confuse things for their ears. Remember, you’re not trying to impress them. You’re trying to get them to sing with you. Make it easy for them. I’d be okay with adding some of the harmonies this time around, but still no descant.
4. Sing Verse 1 – change up the texture. Drop out some extra instruments (synth, flute, tpt, extra guitars, etc.) Have a cantor sing this first verse. It will be a welcome change from the 3 Refrains they just heard (counting the intro). They can really focus on the lyrics sung well by a soloist.
5. Sing the Refrain – now it will be very familiar to everyone. Add the harmonies, but still no descant. Build it up!
6. Sing Verse 2 – perhaps the whole choir/group of singers could sing this verse together. The assembly may or may not catch onto it at this point…but at least they have the Refrain firmly under their belt, so it’s ok. Don’t forget to bring the band back down for the verse. Texture.
7. Sing the Refrain – by this time, everyone knows it very well.
You’ll notice that I never added the descant part in the middle
of the Refrain. Why? Since the song is
so new I think it just confuses things for the assembly. After you’ve sung the song once or twice,
then maybe. But remember…just
because it’s there does not mean you have to sing it! Do what’s best for your church.
As for the end of the Refrain, the descant part wouldn’t be ‘in
the way’ of anything, so it’d be safe to use it. Another option is to put some solo
instruments on those parts, perhaps an octave up.
This approach can apply to any song or arrangement of a song. Every one is different. You really need to think through the best way to introduce the music to fresh ears.
Great article. I agree that we have the assembly sing most of the songs. We have tried multiple things but most of the time they don't sing with us (there could be multiple reasons). Do people at your Church always sing all songs? How many songs do you include in your schedule per week (entrance, psalm, offering, communion, recessional)?
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comment. We do the same as everyone, I imagine: Gathering, Glory, Psalm, Gospel Acc, Preparation, Holy, Mem, Amen, Lamb, Communion 1, Communion 2, Song of Thanksgiving.
ReplyDeleteLike you said, there are a lot of factors that go into assembly participation in the singing of the songs and hymns: Is the key too high/low? Is the volume too loud/soft? Are the instruments and singers in tune? Does the assembly KNOW the music, or is there too much new material? Is the tempo too fast/slow? Do the musicians sound good? Is the music appropriate and singable?
Look and listen to the music from their point of view and see how 'invited' you feel to sing? I've learned a lot that way. Sometimes we get so caught up in what we're doing and how it sounds to US that we forget why we're there!
There are a lot of posts about this very thing covered here in this blog. Please feel free to browse through them. God bless!